Buzz It Up News

Supreme Court Rejects 2 Congressional Districts In North Carolina


States that prevented African Americans from registering to vote or running for office, in addition to other infractions, were singled out by Section 4.

The court's answer in Bethune-Hill and Cooper is that there is a low bar for plaintiffs to show racial predominance, but an even lower bar for surviving strict scrutiny.

"Don't count on Greg Abbott, Dan Patrick or other Texas Republican leaders to listen or care", Angle said in a written statement.

"The context in which the committee has called for General Flynn's testimonial production of documents makes clear that he has more than a reasonable apprehension that any testimony he provides could be used against him", the attorneys wrote in the letter, which was obtained by the AP.

"Regardless of the outcome of the current legal disputes, North Carolina needs a new process for drawing its election maps", said Mitch Kokai, senior political analyst for the John Locke Foundation.

Race can be considered in redrawing boundaries of voting districts only in certain instances, such as when states are seeking to comply with the federal Voting Rights Act. The ruling appears to upend Texas' key argument as it heads back to court over the state's congressional maps.

The court's decision was also welcomed by Democrats, who felt that the legislature's redistricting efforts were systemically unfair to Black voters. They found that this was another example of the excessive use of race in redistricting.

This court ruling is more, and significant, evidence of that. There are, roughly, two types of gerrymandering that come before the court: Gerrymandering by political party, and gerrymandering by race.

"W$3 e uphold the District Court's finding of racial predominance respecting District 12", Kagan wrote. The court said that amounted to an unconstitutional racial gerrymander. Because Harris also failed to produce an alternative map, Alito said he should have lost this case.




Kagan's majority opinion found that the state unconstitutionally used race in drawing the map for CD1.

This result is important for three reasons. The Supreme Court affirmed that ruling. But the court pointed out that black candidates have been winning that district for years with substantial support from white voters, so a majority-black district wasn't needed.

Both districts are held by Democrats. Similarly, in Cooper, the court held that a court may find racial predominance even if the plaintiffs can not propose a competing plan that provides greater racial balance. He agreed that the court had correctly deferred to the lower court's plausible interpretation of the evidence.

Second, in rejecting the competing-plan test, the court rejected one of the best ways to distinguish districting plans that warrant judicial intervention from those that do not. Is it politics or is it race? Not so in Washington, where a bipartisan commission is tasked with determining the outlay of districts. Easley cemented the notion that states may gerrymander along partisan lines, even where race and political affiliation are intertwined.

In the coming months, the court is expected to weigh in on a case from Wisconsin involving partisan, not racial, gerrymandering. That law protects minority voters and was enacted to address a history of racial discrimination in voting, especially in Southern states.

Just last month, civil rights groups filed a lawsuit challenging Georgia house districts drawn in 2015.

The split among the justices was over the 12th district.

African-American and Democratic critics accused Republicans of drawing districts to contain more African Americans than necessary to keep surrounding districts more white and more Republican. I don't know if this is good decision for voters, but it is definitely a good decision for redistricting lawyers.

Related Articles

  • Oil prices fall on White House proposal to sell United States oil reserves

    In fact, the rapid response by the USA shale sector to the OPEC deal helps explain why oil prices retreated earlier this month. Brent for July settlement fell 52 cents to $53.35 a barrel on the London-based ICE Futures Europe exchange.
    Josh Harrop makes history with record-breaking Manchester United goal

    Josh Harrop makes history with record-breaking Manchester United goal

    At the end of the first half, Michael Carrick came on for Pogba and moments later Anthony Martial entered for Jesse Lingard. Jamie Redknapp says there is "no joy" in the Manchester United team under Jose Mourinho.
    Mortgage Rates Friday, May 19: Still Near 6-Month Lows

    Mortgage Rates Friday, May 19: Still Near 6-Month Lows

    As a result, many prospective homebuyers who can not come up with a 20 percent down payment are unable to get a loan. 3/1 Adjustable Rate Mortgages are being quoted at 3.000% with an April of 3.744%.
  • Flanagan Backs Varadkar To Be

    Flanagan Backs Varadkar To Be "Courageous" Fine Gael Leader

    Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny speaks to the media at the general election count centre in Castlebar, Ireland February 27, 2016. Another senior member said: "The body language of some of his loyal supporters said it all, there were a few teary eyes".
    Twin Peaks' Mark Frost talks of 'liberating freedom'

    Twin Peaks' Mark Frost talks of 'liberating freedom'

    David Lynch advised fans to watch the Twin Peaks' movie, Fire Walk With Me , that aired after the series went off the air. The eight-month shoot began in fall 2015, and initially MacLachlan found that reinhabiting the role was a challenge.
    IS slays scores of civilians in Syria

    IS slays scores of civilians in Syria

    A medical source told the media that those wounded were admitted to the Salamiyeh National Hospital. He said at least nine children were beaten on the head with heavy objects such as bricks or stones.
  • Charlie Hunnam not first choice for 'King Arthur...'

    Charlie Hunnam not first choice for 'King Arthur...'

    Needless to say, we are absolutely thrilled at the prospect of a musical done in that high energy, frenetic Ritchie style. While he had a filmed named after him, Bend it like Beckham , he did not appear in that film - a lookalike was used.
    Aamir Khan shares his favorite memory of Sachin Tendulkar

    Aamir Khan shares his favorite memory of Sachin Tendulkar

    Tendulkar says that in the movie, he has revealed what went through his mind during the lowest point of his career. With AR Rahman's score "Hind Mere Jind" already making waves, and the musical rendition of the popular "Sachin".
    Browns To Sign Veteran CB Jason McCourty

    Browns To Sign Veteran CB Jason McCourty

    Heading into the upcoming season, it appears as though McCourty will be an immediate starter on the opposite side of Haden. I want to be a part of something where I felt like I'm wanted and where I feel like I'm part of a family.
  • Macron and Merkel Signal New Move to Strengthen Eurozone

    Macron and Merkel Signal New Move to Strengthen Eurozone

    The French and German leaders pledged to relaunch the partnership between their two countries in order to "reconstruct" the EU. French and German leaders announce they agreed on a "road map" for future European Union reform and pledge close cooperation.

    AT&T workers prepare for a three-day strike

    AT&T , for its part, said that the company is prepared for workers to walk off the job but continues to negotiate. The held signs reading "On Strike" as customers went in and out of the store and pedestrians walked by.
    Shawn Mendes On His 'Unreal' Billboard Music Award Nominations

    Shawn Mendes On His 'Unreal' Billboard Music Award Nominations

    So as these awards enter their 24th edition in some hours, here's all you must know about this year's event. The chart topping hit song has earned Wizkid seven Billboard Music Awards nominations.

Comments